Influencer Marketing

5 Decisions Every Brand Should Make When Choosing Influencers

Most brands focus only on follower count when selecting creators, but there are 5 critical decisions to make. Learn the framework for evaluating results, audience fit, budget, brand alignment, and trust.

2 min read

Paulina SánchezFounder & CEO at RealUp
5 Decisions Every Brand Should Make When Choosing Influencers

Every influencer you choose comes with 5 decisions.

Most brands only focus on one: How many followers do they have?

But that's only 1 of the 5.

Here are 5 questions I ask before choosing any creator:

1. Results: Can they help us reach our goal?

Their past campaigns show whether they work best for awareness, consideration or conversion.

→ Check their past campaigns. Did they get views, clicks, or sales?

2. Audience: Are we reaching the right people?

A large audience is useful when it includes the people your campaign is for, so knowing who watches matters as much as knowing how many.

→ Check where their followers live, their age, and what language they speak.

3. Budget: Are they worth the money?

Comparing each fee with what that creator brings helps you choose the mix that fits your goal.

→ Compare what each creator charges with the results they can deliver.

4. Brand fit: Do they match our brand?

Their values, their tone, and the way they talk to their audience become part of how people see you.

→ Look at what they post, how they speak, and the brands they've worked with.

5. Trust: Will people believe their recommendation?

A recommendation works when it sounds like something that creator would say anyway.

If they promoted a competitor last month, people may question why they're recommending yours now.

→ Check whether their recommendations feel genuine and how their audience reacts.

Here's the part many brands miss:

You don't need every creator to do the same thing.

One might help thousands of people discover your brand.

Another might convince a smaller group to buy your product.

The goal is to find the right mix of creators for your campaign.